| 4-TIME CONFERENCE CHAMPIONS |
| 1 | Matt Ashley | Spencer | 1976-98 | 1977-105 | 1978-119 | 1979-132 |
| 2 | Lester Hughart | St. Marys | 1982-98 | 1983-105 | 1984-112 | 1985-119 |
| 3 | Orarn Butler | St. Marys | 1988-103 | 1989-112 | 1990-125 | 1991-125 |
| 4 | Mike Mason | Williamstown | 1990-112 | 1991-119 | 1992-135 | 1993-140 |
| 5 | Jon Brindo | Wirt County | 1991-130 | 1992-140 | 1993-145 | 1994-145 |
| 6 | Danny Life | Wirt County | 1992-103 | 1993-112 | 1994-119 | 1995-119 |
| 7 | David Drennen | Wirt County | 1995-103 | 1996-112 | 1997-125 | 1998-160 |
| 8 | Mike Miller | Wirt County | 1996-103 | 1997-119 | 1998-125 | 1999-140 |
| 3-TIME CONFERENCE CHAMPIONS |
| 1 | Herman Full | Wirt County | 1964-106 | 1965-115 | 1966-123 |
| 2 | Mark Hale | Wirt County | 1965-106 | 1966-115 | 1967-120 |
| 3 | Mike Goodwin | Wirt County | 1966-UNL | 1967-180 | 1968-UNL |
| 4 | Bill Mason | Williamstown | 1970-107 | 1971-115 | 1972-115 |
| 5 | Rod Watson | Wirt County | 1971-UNL | 1972-188 | 1973-188 |
| 6 | Rocky Corbin | Ravenswood | 1972-122 | 1973-129 | 1974-135 |
| 7 | John Boley | Spencer | 1972-148 | 1973-148 | 1974-148 |
| 8 | Randy Ash | Spencer | 1974-98 | 1975-98 | 1976-112 |
| 9 | Terry Kendall | Spencer | 1978-167 | 1979-185 | 1980-185 |
| 10 | Steve Jordan | Ripley | 1980-119 | 1981-119 | 1982-126 |
| 11 | Eric Butler | Williamstown | 1981-98 | 1982-105 | 1983-119 |
| 12 | Dan Rowell | Williamstown | 1981-105 | 1982-119 | 1983-126 |
| 13 | Jeff Hughart | St Marys | 1983-112 | 1985-145 | 1986-145 |
| 14 | Joe Hefner | St Marys | 1986-105 | 1988-135 | 1989-152 |
| 15 | Todd Kendall | Spencer | 1988-119 | 1989-125 | 1990-130 |
| 16 | Tom Greathouse | Spencer | 1988-130 | 1989-140 | 1990-145 |
| 17 | John Heath | Ravenswood | 1990-103 | 1991-112 | 1992-112 |
| 18 | Donnie Hickman | Wirt County | 1990-140 | 1991-140 | 1992-145 |
| 19 | Mike Sheppard | Wirt County | 1990-119 | 1992-152 | 1993-160 |
| 20 | Toby Ray | Wirt County | 1991-152 | 1992-160 | 1993-189 |
| 21 | Joe Shuman | Williamstown | 1993-119 | 1994-130 | 1995-135 |
| 22 | Dennie Uhl | Williamstown | 1994-152 | 1995-152 | 1996-160 |
| 23 | Ash Wenmoth | Williamstown | 1998-103 | 1999-112 | 2000-125 |
| 24 | Jason Hayhurst | Ritchie County | 1998-119 | 1999-125 | 2000-130 |
| 25 | Ashley Gandee | Ravenswood | 1999-103 | 2000-112 | 2001-112 |
| 26 | Chris Morris | Calhoun County | 2000-103 | 2001-119 | 2002-125 |
| 27 | Ryan Delebreau | Williamstown | 2000-189 | 2001-189 | 2002-189 |
| 28 | Shane Smith | Williamstown | 2001-135 | 2002-145 | 2003-160 |
| 29 | Ray Burge | Calhoun County | 2001-171 | 2002-171 | 2003-171 |
| OUTSTANDING CONFERENCE WRESTLERS |
| 1973 | Byrd Wolfe | Walton | 119 |
| 1974 | John Boley | Spencer | 145 |
| 1975 | K.D. Lamp | St Marys | 138 |
| 1976 | Mike Doonan | Parkersburg Catholic | 132 |
| 1977 | Jeff Braham | Spencer | 185 |
| 1978 | Fred Tawney | Spencer | 126 |
| 1979 | Matt Ashley | Spencer | 132 |
| 1980 | Terry Kendall | Spencer | 185 |
| 1981 | Gene Morris | Ravenswood | 155 |
| 1982 | Malcolm Ashley | Calhoun County | 145 |
| 1983 | Jeff Smith | Williamstown | 155 |
| 1984 | Mike Roberts | Spencer | 138 |
| 1985 | Lester Hughart | St Marys | 119 |
| 1986 | Bill Hughart | St Marys | 119 |
| 1987 | John Ferguson | Wirt County | 155 |
| 1988 | Joe Hufner | St Marys | 135 |
| 1989 | Tom Greathouse | Spencer | 145 |
| 1990 | Paul Staton | Calhoun County | 152 |
| 1991 | Oran Butler | St Marys | 125 |
| 1992 | John Heath | Ravenswood | 112 |
| 1993 | Mike Mason | Williamstown | 140 |
| 1994 | Jon Brindo | Wirt County | 145 |
| 1995 | Danny Life | Wirt County | 119 |
| 1996 | Dennie Uhl | Williamstown | 160 |
| 1997 | Josh Cross | Wirt County | 112 |
| 1998 | Adam Schlinder | Ravenswood | 112 |
| 1999 | Mike Miller | Wirt County | 140 |
| 2000 | Robert Kimball | St Marys | 171 |
| 2001 | Robert Stutler | Clay | 152 |
| 2002 | Justin Ashley | Calhoun County | 112 |
| 2003 | Shane Smith | Williamstown | 160 |